Tom in Iraq as a Military Observer

Tom in Iraq as a Military Observer
They sent me here just to watch...
Showing posts with label Libya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Libya. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 23, 2011

Gaddaffi Captured!

Gaddaffi Captured!
Or Qaddafi killed.
Or Gaddaffi surfaces in Yemen.
Or Muammar Gaddaffi still at large.

These are the headlines many are waiting for as they watch the 24 hour news stations.
None of these are the main story line in Libya.
What is?
That regime change will have come from within with support from western powers and the concurrence of the Arab League.
Unlike Iraq and Afghanistan where regime change was produced by external, mainly U.S. forces; Libya is a case study in a true popular movement in the Middle East.  This is what President George H. W. Bush had hope for in Iraq at the end of the first Gulf War.
While entry into this conflict further eroded the liberty of all Americans; Libyans are tasting an opportunity to engage in self rule, and perhaps even some form of democracy.  This was a movement that began with the Libyan people.
Statesmen from around the globe should be more focused on offering assistance on an as requested basis.  Supporting nations should be reserved, but responsive when the requests are presented.  That is, let’s not be pushy, but let’s be on time once the new government needs help being the new government.
The United States needed a little help from France in the Revolutionary War, but this continental revolt was surely an American affair.  Likewise, what is happening in Libya is home grown change.  Let’s see how this goes if we stay in the background and only help when asked.
There is one more to add to the list of Gaffaffi possibilities.  Gaddaffi counter attacks!  We have the luxury of looking to the future.  In Libya, these makeshift militiamen still have a fight to finish.

Monday, March 21, 2011

Now is the time for Congress to reclaim its authority to declare war

Qaddafi surely ranks among the worst leaders of the past fifty years.
Most people believe that Libya would be better off without him.
Almost a quarter century ago I was aboard the U.S.S. Saipan as part of a sizeable naval force that crossed the so called Line of Death that Qaddafi had supposedly drawn in the Gulf of Sidra.   He did nothing.  Had he done anything: we would have responded.   I would have believed it to be a just cause and would have gladly led Marines to welcome this yahoo to the infernal regions
Today, Qaddafi is still an affront to leadership but one which the international community has somehow accepted as a perennial institution in Libya.
The world would be better off without Qaddafi. 
I can’t believe we attacked Libya.  That’s not quite true.  I don’t want to believe that we attacked Libya.
Why?   I thought the guy was a total jerk and the world would be better off without him.
True, but we are worse off for doing this.  In what has gone virtually unnoticed by the American people, the President of the United States engaged United States military forces as if he were throwing a dollar ante into a Friday night poker game.
Where has the compromised constitution—better known as the War Powers Act—gone?
Can the President truly treat the Congress of the United States as an ancient Privy Council, consulting as he deems appropriate?
From Truman to Obama the authority to declare war has been on a pilgrimage from Congress to the President without the courtesy of swinging by the age old friend known as the Constitutional Amendment.
But what about the War Powers Act?
It was doomed in its genesis.  For an ordinary law to restrain a president when the Supreme Law of the Land has been ignored for over half a century is but a political placebo taken so we do not have to take our real medicine.
The authority to declare war resides in the Congress because that body of selfless public servants, self-serving knuckleheads, doctors, lawyers, saints, sinners, and everything in between is most representative of the will of the people. 
Our Founding Fathers knew that war is something not to be taken lightly.  It was not to be avoided at all costs, but it was not to be entered into without the will of the people who trusted their authority to those elected to represent them.
Does Qaddafi need to hit the road?  I can think of as many reasons to say yes as there are spellings of Kaddafi. 
Does the use of our nation’s military forces for war fighting purposes need to be preceded by a declaration of war?   Yes!
If we truly want to preserve the American way of life for ourselves and our posterity, we need Congress to man-up and reclaim the authority to declare war once again.  That means that they must be willing to impeach and convict any president who would defy the Constitution of the United States from this point forward.
It’s time for Congress to step up to this ultimate leadership task.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Are we going to war in Libya?

Is the talk of the day really about attacking Libya?
It seems to be.
The thinking is that if the U.S. were to impose or lead a coalition to impose a no-fly zone in the country ruled with an iron hand by Moammar Gadhafi for decades, it must first be preceded by an air campaign to knock out command and control capability and the ability to retaliate against enforcers of the no-fly zone.  To simply attempt to impose a no-fly zone without this preparatory step is to offer the Libyan Air Force a chance to engage in a more even fight.
Where did these no-fly zone requests come from?
Somewhat anonymous requests offered up by random, or perhaps more accurately by media hungry individuals among the rebels, seem to be generating action in our nation’s capital.
But to what extreme is the United States willing to respond?
To whom would we be responding?
Would we not be initiating an act of war that is not directly tied to a recent provocation?  In the 1980’s I was aboard the USS Saipan as we joined other US warships to cross the line of death in the Gulf of Sidra and thumb our collective noses at Gadhafi in hopes of provoking him into attacking any part of the US Fleet just so we would have a good reason to wipe his administration off the map.  But what are we responding to in 2011?
Granted, the world would probably be a better place without mush-for-brains Gadhafi in it.  Yes, in another context, I would use a more descriptive term than mush, but do we once again put our troops in harm’s way to remove this idiot?
What is in our national interest?  Today, that phrase is sometimes interchangeable with the word oil.  The interesting thing is that many don’t even bat an eye anymore that we would spill American blood to stabilize the price at the pump.
For over sixty years, we have wrestled with the question:  Are we the world’s policemen?
We have yet to develop a coherent policy to guide us through this recurring quagmire.  When do we exert the military might of this once peaceful nation and when do we let things run their course?
If American armed forces are called, they will respond with professionalism and selflessness.  Every U.S. commander is ready to lead his unit into battle but is also prayerful that those who issue the call to arms are judicious with our most precious military asset—our service men and women.  We as the American Electorate need to be more vocal with our leaders as to when we are willing to spill the blood of these men and women.
This is a call for our land of the free and home of the brave to pause, pray, and listen to the Almighty before we jump in just because we can.
It may be the right thing to do.  It may be the humanitarian thing to do.  It may be best for our national interest, but let’s wrestle with that question before we commit to battle.